Matt and Lauren, Davis CA. 2022 Highlander Platinum AWD, 2013 Sienna LE, 2010 Town & Country.
Best price
$1,757
Progressive, per 6 months, paid in full (with med pay, rental, gap)
Savings vs current
~$933
per 6 months
Per year
~$1,866
saved, with better coverage
Current cost
~$2,690
per 6 months, weaker coverage
Recommendation: Go with Progressive. The revised quote (occupation, some college, Lauren licensed at 16, plus med pay, rental, and gap) is $1,757 paid in full. That is about $933 less than what you pay now and about $331 less than Allstate as a new customer at $2,088. Other carrier quotes do not include med pay, rental, or gap.
Compare quotes
Target coverage for all quotes unless noted: BI 100/300, PD 100k, UM/UIM 100/300, $500 comp and collision on the Highlander and Sienna, liability only on the Town & Country.
Progressive's $1,757 includes med pay ($5k), Highlander rental ($40/day), and Highlander loan/lease payoff. The other carriers below were quoted without those add-ons, so Progressive's lead is even larger than the table suggests.
Carrier
Price
Monthly
Annual
Savings vs current
Glass
JDP claims
JDP CA sat.
NAIC
CA DOI
AM Best
Tap a column header to sort. Swipe sideways to see service scores. Savings follow the selected period. For J.D. Power, higher is better. For NAIC and CA DOI complaint ratios, lower is better (NAIC 1.00 is average).
Sienna liability-only is priced only for GEICO. Progressive's old liability-only figure is stale after the profile and add-on changes and needs a requote.
Price chart
Carrier details
Tap a carrier to see the breakdown, discounts, and pros and cons.